Hello dear
Welcome To Millie's Pizza
At Millie's Pizza, located in New Buffalo, PA, pizza lovers are treated to an exceptional dining experience. This charming, family-owned eatery offers a diverse menu featuring mouthwatering pizzas, hot subs, salads, and a kid-friendly option. Customers rave about the Steak Lover's Pizza and the various cheesesteaks that showcase high-quality ingredients and generous portions. With a commitment to friendly service, Millie's Pizza also provides convenient delivery, ensuring hot meals reach you at your campsite or home. Whether you're winding down after a long day or seeking a delicious meal, Millie's Pizza promises to satisfy with every bite, making it a local favorite.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Plain Cheese
Chicken Parmigiana
Hamburger
Pizza Burger
About
Millie's Pizza
Welcome to Millie's Pizza, a delightful gem located at 34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA. This local eatery is more than just a pizza place; it embodies the spirit of community and family warmth. As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I had the pleasure of exploring their diverse menu, and let me tell you, Millie's Pizza does not disappoint.
From their personal pizzas priced at just $7.00, perfect for kids and adults alike, to hearty party subs like the Italian sub for $27.50, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. And if you're looking to savor something light, their range of fresh salads showcases a variety of options like the Grilled Chicken Salad and the Buffalo Chicken Salad, each priced at $10.75. It’s a menu that promises quality at an affordable price.
What truly sets Millie's Pizza apart, aside from its tempting offerings, is the unyielding quality of service. Customers rave about their experiences—Shayne Smith shared their delightful encounter after a long day of moving, emphasizing the superb sub and incredible service. Alvin Owens, a truck driver, was pleasantly surprised by the Steak Lover's Pizza delivered straight to his truck stop. It's these personal touches that make Millie's Pizza not just a meal, but a cherished memory.
The owners, a dedicated local family, work tirelessly to create a welcoming atmosphere and provide exceptional food. They go above and beyond, even surprising regulars with little gifts, enhancing the dining experience beyond just the food. This commitment to customer satisfaction resonates deeply with patrons, as highlighted by Adrienne Checchio's praise of Millie's being the best pizza around.
If you’re camping by the Juniata River or staying nearby, you'll find that Millie's Pizza is a fantastic option for when you want a break from cooking. With the convenience of delivery to campsites, this team ensures you receive your meal hot and fresh, eliminating any stress about finding them.
In conclusion, my visit to Millie’s Pizza was marked by flavorful dishes, warm hospitality, and a cozy ambiance that feels like home. Whether you’re indulging in a classic pepperoni pizza or diving into a fresh salad, Millie's Pizza is sure to leave a lasting impression. It truly embodies what a local eatery should be—a perfect blend of delicious food and a vibrant community spirit. Don’t miss out; visit or call +1 717-834-6565 to experience the joy of Millie's Pizza for yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We just moved to new buffalo and after a day of moving, there was no way I was cooking dinner. We decided to check out our local pizza place and oh my goodness! It was the best sub I’ve ever had! The price point is fantastic and the service even better. I realized half way through eating that I forgot the tip so I walked down to rectify that and check out the location. Super cute! Can’t wait to order again!! ”
“ I drive a truck and they delivered this awesome pizza right to me @ the truck stop up the road where I'm staying. This is their Steak Lover's Pizza. Very nice people. ”
“ Owned by an amazing local family! Best pizza around! And we are so lucky to have them close to home. ”
“ We got a seasonal site at riverfront campground, and Millie’s was highly recommended by some long term residents. The great thing is they deliver directly to the campsite, and you don’t have to worry about them finding you. They also take cards upon delivery. We’ve been ordering all season, and the owner surprised us with a little gift, can’t beat the service, and the pizza is always hot and fresh. If you’re staying on the juniata river side, Millie’s is definitely a must try! Definitely makes it easy when you don’t feel like cooking! ”
“ We were staying in a little camper / Airbnb in Duncannon and we decided to go find something for dinner...we were Googling places and suddenly my little lady looked to her right and there was Milly's Pizza. We stopped and ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and onions. We took it back to out Airbnb...OMG !!!!!!!!!! THAT WAS THE BEST PIZZA I'VE HAD IN A LOOOOONG TIME. The staff were quite professional and very curious. An amazing experience...thank you soon much... ”
“ I've been getting food from Millie's for about 10 years now. The food is always excellent. Once in a while there's a small mistake but considering they help the young community by employing some kids as their first time job, I can see past it. All in all this place is a must if you're in the area or even passing through. ”
“ We have never actually eaten inside Millie’s but it’s a cute little old house right off the highway. Their dough is fantastic, we haven’t had a single thing we haven’t liked from here. But let me just say the absolute joy it brings me that they DELIVER. We live near the ferry boat campground which is 10 minutes away and it always arrives within the time (or sooner) provided. The ONLY thing I’d like to say is they don’t provide bread with salad which is just probably something I’m trained to think from other pizza shopped but no reason to take away a star. Thanks Millie’s! ”
“ We stumbled into this place while riding our motorcycles back to VA through some awesome trails in the PA area. Family owned and operated. Everyone was very friendly and the pizza was fantastic. Spoke to the owner for a bit about motorcycles, MTB, and Drones.... Instantly felt welcome. Small-town hospitality done right. ”